Section 13 - Passive radiators
Wednesday, 09-Jul-2008, 11:07:48 GMT
Last modified: 25-Mar-2007, 19:49:51 GMT








Go to….

Introduction
Materials legend
Recommendations
Notes



Passive radiators:

Passive radiators (PR's), are also known as auxiliary bass radiators (ABR's) and "drone cones". Simply stated these are woofer/subwoofer chassis with cones but no motor. The only characteristics of PR's are their excursion limit, compliance, and their resonant frequency (determined mostly by cone mass). PR systems use one or more woofers in a sealed box with a PR. Since the box is sealed and the PR has no magnetic motor, the PR's motion is entirely determined by the air in the enclosure and the back wave of the woofer(s). System design and modeling are exactly as for a ported system, except the port tuning is replaced by adjusting the PR's mass to match the mass of the air in an equivalent vent with the same cross-sectional area as the Sd of the PR. For best results, the PR should therefore have low mass, a compliant suspension capable of wide excursions, and a resonant frequency below both the box and port tuning frequencies.

Any DIY'er can make a PR from an old woofer by simply removing the magnet and voice coil assembly, leaving only the chassis and cone. This is generally not a good idea. The PR's "Xmax" will be equal to Xsus of the driver. Without the constraints of motor design, PR designers can achieve outrageously high vales of Xsus. As might be expected, along with the PR's typically compliant suspension, this raises Vas considerably. Furthermore, good PR's typically use much more massive cones than drivers, resulting in a subsonic Fs and a very high Qms. For more professional (and cosmetically pleasing) results, there are several commercial sources of PR's listed below. The currently preeminent source for general purpose PR's is Stryke Audio. There are several vendors who produce PR's specially designed to work one or more of their own drivers.

For more information on PR's in general, read "Passive Radiator Enclosures: In Theory and In Practice" by Adam Bird.


Materials legend (sorted alphabetically):

Material Description
FCX Earthquake proprietary composite.
Paper Paper, possible treated or coated.
Nomex Peerless thick NomexTM paper.
PP Polypropylene.
Foam Expanded foam.
MDF Medium density fiberboard.


Recommended PR's (sorted by vendor, diameter, and price):

Vendor 1 Model Size
(inches)
Price
($-USD)
Type Fs
(Hz)
Xmax
(mm)
Mms
(grams)
Vas
(liters)
Qms
Adire PR15 2 15  90  Flat MDF 8.2  31.0 285  1187  5.4 
Earthquake P1220 3 12  125  Flat FCX 20.0  20.0 N.A.3 N.A. N.A.
Human 049 29  Paper cone 20.0  8.9 N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
015 10  32  Paper cone 12.0  11.0 N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
023 12  37  Paper cone 10.0  12.7 N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
Madisound 8100PR8 17  PP cone N.A. N.A. N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
10100PR10 10  20  PP cone N.A. N.A. N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
12100PR12 12  25  PP cone N.A. N.A. N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
15100PR15 15  39  PP cone N.A. N.A. N.A.4 N.A. N.A.
Peerless 630468 10  56  Nomex cone 13.7 22.0 256  80 11.4
630481 10  56  Nomex cone 11.2 22.0 400  80 14.0
630548 12  60  Nomex cone 10.4 24.0 425  170 15.2
Seas SP17R 6.5  27  PP cone 26.0 9.5 22 4 41 N.A.
SP21R 33  PP cone 22.0 10.0 28 4 138 N.A.
SP25R 10  39  PP cone 22.0 11.0 42 4 214 N.A.
Stryke SA-PR10-80 10  55  Flat MDF 21.3  38.0  80  122  21.4 
SA-PR10-300 10  55  Flat MDF 11.0  38.0  300  122  41.4 
SA-PR12-450 12  58  Flat MDF 9.0  42.0  450  279  50.7 
SA-PR12-670 12  59  Flat MDF 7.3  42.0  670  279  61.9 
SA-PR15-430 15  60  Flat MDF 7.7  50.0  430  685  41.5 
SA-PR15-700 15  60  Flat MDF 6.0  50.0  700  685  52.9 
SA-PR15-1050 15  62  Flat MDF 4.9  50.0  1050  685  64.8 
SA-PR15-1400 15  65  Flat MDF 4.3  50.0  1400  685  74.8 
SA-PR18-1600 18  99  Flat MDF 4.0  50.0  1600  2045  85.0 
SA-PR18-2500D 18  114  Flat MDF 3.4  50.0  2500  1840  92.0 

Notes:

  1. See driver manufacturers section(s) for contact and/or distribution information.
  2. The PR15 is specially designed for the Adire 12" Shiva and 15" Tempest subwoofers.
  3. The P1220 is specially designed for the 12" Earthquake Magma 12 subwoofer.
  4. All PR's with low values of Mms are assumed to require that the user add mass as required to tune the PR.




©1998-2007 by Bob Stout, all rights reserved

Tested with: Get Firefox Get MSIE .

Support: Rapid PHP