|
I haven't received as much feedback about Morel as for some other vendors,
but what I have received was all positive - some bordering on fanatically so.
This isn't surprising since Morel licenses some of its technology from
Dynaudio, another vendor which elicits extreme opinions (Morel and Dynaudio,
in turn, both license some technology from Scan-Speak). Morel's units all
look quite good - although hardly exceptional - on paper,
so apparently they're doing something right. Probably, their apparent
emphasis on power handling and linearity deserve most of the credit.
Morel's line of woofer and mid/bass units deserve further comment. Traditionally,
Morel's LF drivers tended to high Q's and low sensitivity. These
drivers worked best in sealed enclosures. Recently, Morel introduced their
new "Neolin" line of drivers. Once you get past the hype to the specs, you
realize that the main difference in the Neolin line is that they're much
better suited to vented systems.
As a final note, in addition to explicitly shielded drivers, all of Morel's
double magnet, non-Neolin drivers feature very low stray magnetic fields and
can therefore usually be used in applications usually requiring a shielded
driver.
In 2003, a feud broke out between Morel USA, and its parent company in
Israel. The confusing result of this is that the two separate companies have
established separate distribution channels, each using the Morel name. The
good news is that all of the classic Morel drivers are available from both
company's distributors. The bad news is that all of the newer drivers are
proprietary to one or the other and are therefore only carried by that company's
distributors. To date, I have primarily received recommendations for the
classic Morel designs, with the exception of the two new Supreme tweeters.
Standouts among Morel's designs include:
- The MDT33 tweeter has a very
devoted following. It features include a sophisticated double magnet design and
back chamber, plus lots of attention to linearity. Those who recommend it also
point out its ability to cleanly handle prodigious amounts of power as well as
its low end extension which allows crossovers as low as 1.4 kHz. Some have also
recommended the use of a Zobel to sweeten the top end.
view
response
waterfall
| Note: |
The MDT33, laong with the
Accuton C223/6,
Hiquphon OW I/II/III,
Human 002,
Scan-Speak R2904/7000, and the
Alison Acoustics 4010203
(available only as a replacement part for Allison loudspeakers) are
considered by many to be the ultimate electrodynamic tweeters.
|
- The Supreme 110
tweeter is the new sucessor to the venerable MDT33 from Morel/Israel.
Featuring a neodymium magnet and an underhung motor (a rarity in a
tweeter) for lower distortion, and using a large diameter VC and coated
textile dome, it shares most of the MDT33's characteristic virtues, but
is roughly 1 dB less sensitive. Although not shielded, its neodymium
magnet also produces less stray magnetic field than the MDT33. Reports
put it in the top echelon of currently available conventional tweeters,
while still costing only about 15% more than the MDT33. All
Supreme 110's are packaged as matched pairs.
view
response
waterfall
impedance
phase
- The Supreme 130
tweeter is an interesting variant of the Supreme 110, described
above. It features a larger diameter face plate than the Supreme 110
(130 mm vs.110 mm). This allows the actual driver to mounted
off-center in the faceplate. This neatly solves the problem of mounting
the tweeter as closely as possible to the midrange or mid/bass driver
without resorting to a square or rectangular face plate with all the
mounting problems that entails. The Supreme 130, selling at nearly
$100 more per pair than the Supreme 110 is targeted at the extreme
high end. As with the Supreme 110, the Supreme 130 comes only
in matched pairs, but with individual performance documentation.
view
response
waterfall
impedance
phase
- The MDT30,
DMS30, and
MDT32 tweeters are all lower-cost
single-magnet alternatives to the MDT33. The principle differences between the
models is that the face plate of the MDT30 is 94 mm (3.7") in diameter, while
the MD32 is larger at 110 mm (4.3") in diameter. Magnetically shielded versions
of the MDT30 and MDT32, called the DMS30 and DMS32, respectively, are available
for use in home theater applications. Most of the MDT33 performance comments
apply to these drivers except that these are 2.5 dB less sensitive than the
MDT33.
MDT30/MDT32 view
MDT30/MDT32 response
MDT30/MDT32 waterfall
DMS30 view
DMS32 view
- The MDT39 and MDT40 tweeters are, in most respects identical to
the MDT30/32 tweeters. Their primary differences are their diminutive 54 mm
(2-1/8") square face plate. One of the side effects of the reduced size is
reduced continuous power handling and lower sensitivity ( 1 dB for the MDT40, 3
dB for the MDT39) compared to the MDT30/32 drivers. The MDT39 and MDT40 are
shielded for use in home theater applications. Aside from sensitivity, the
principle difference between the two is the MDT39's slightly cleaner FR and
waterfall plots.
MDT39 view
MDT39 response
MDT39 waterfall
MDT40 view
MDT40 response
MDT40 waterfall
- The MDT37 is a semi-horn
loaded tweeter which features excellent sound as well as 93 dB
sensitivity. It shares all of the other Morel tweeter virtues, meaning it's one
of the cleanest sounding high-sensitivity tweeters you can find. A shielded
version, the DMS37, is also available.
MDT37 view
MDT37 response
MDT37 waterfall
- The MDT20 is Morel's
idea of a low-cost tweeter. Featuring a plastic face plate, but with more
expensive features such as a rear chamber and ferrofluid, it's somewhat
more expensive than other low-cost tweeters, but features all of Morel's
traditional tweeter qualities - high power handling, low distortion,
silky smoothness, and great sound.
view
response
waterfall
- The MDT22 tweeter is an
alternative implementation of the MDT20 low-cost tweeter goal. This time,
Morel used a very small face plate with a neodymium motor to create an
attractive shielded driver. Because of the geometry, a minor glitch in
the MDT-20's response around 15 kHz is magnified in the MDT-22. All other
MDT-20 comments apply.
view
response
waterfall
- The MDT41 tweeter is an
externally mounted version of the MDT40. Offering the same high level of
performance as the MDT40, the MDT41 includes a convenient and easy to install
mounting kit.
view
response
waterfall
- The MDM55 2" soft dome midrange
is a descendent to their well-regarded MDM85 unit. One of the few dome midrange
units which actually deliver on their promise, the MDT55 features extremely flat
response with good extension and well controlled roll off at both ends of its
passband. As with all Morel drivers, it can handle lots of power without damage
or distress and can tolerate low order crossovers. One user reported excellent
results using a set of MDM55's to replace the original Vifa midrange drivers in
a Dunlavy SC-V system.
view
response
waterfall
- The MW114-S 4" dual magnet,
damped polymer composite (DPC) coned midrange (called a woofer by Morel) offers
smooth, extended response along with an exceptionally high Xmax for a 4" driver.
This uses their latest neodymium magnet technology and features a high ratio of
VC-to-cone diameter.
view
response
waterfall
- The MW142 5" dual magnet,
damped polymer composite (DPC) coned mid/bass offers smooth, extended response,
albeit with a small plateau between 1-3 kHz.The MW142 uses Morel's dual
magnet technology and features a high ratio of VC-to-cone diameter. As noted,
Morel licenses much of its technology from Dynaudio and the MW142 is Morel's
version of the venerable Dynaudio 15W-75.
view
response
impedance
- Morel makes three 6" DPC mid/bass drivers. All feature a large 3" diameter
VC, and all have similar performance, varying in specific details. All have been
recommended.
- The MW166 double magnet driver
has a notably smooth FR. This is a classic Morel design, featuring high Qts,
low Vas, 86 dB/W/m sensitivity, and a higher Fs then the following drivers.
Notably, it has a large 4.25 mm Xmax.
view
response
waterfall
- The MW167 Neolin motor (see
below) driver also has the 4.25 mm Xmax of the MW166, but features a lower
values of Qts and Fs, with a higher Vas and 88 dB sensitivity. Its FR curve
is not as flat as the MW166's, having a slight rising tilt.
view
- The MW168 double magnet driver
(a standard Morel driver, but only Madisound advertises it) is similar to
the MW167 in having lower Qts and Fs than the MW166, higher Vas, and 88
dB/W/m sensitivity, but Xmax is only 3.5 mm. As with the MW166, it's FR is
slightly better than the MW167.
view
- The MW267 is an 8" neodymium
magnet woofer, also using Morel's latest Neolin motor and construction
technology. Like all Morel woofers, it's a good performer with good curves,
numbers, and notable power handling and linearity. Unlike other Morel
woofers, this lower-Q, higher compliance design is one of the first using
their new "Neolin" technology.
view
response
- The MW1077 is a 10" woofer using Neolin technology. This relatively high-Q
driver would work quite well in a sealed or transmission line enclosure.
Although Fs could be lower and Xmax could be higher, the FR curve is commendably
flat throughout its operating range.
view
response
- The MW1075 is a double magnet 10" woofer with DPC cone. Although not quite
the match for the MW1077 in most respects, it's one of the few 10" drivers with
a low enough external magnetic field to be used near TV's or monitors.
view
New drivers from Morel/Israel are the only ones for which I have received
feedback as of this writing. These include the Supreme tweeters and the H
(hybrid motor) series.
New drivers to watch for from Morel/USA are all designated as the "Shabani" series,
after Mikhael Shabani, Morel/USA's founder and chief designer. As with
Morel/Israel, I haven't received sufficient feedback to recommend these yet, but
the Shabani line includes:
- There is a single 1.1" (28 mm) soft dome tweeter which doesn't appear to
break any new technical ground. Presumably, it will still share Morel's
excellent reputation for tweeters.
- The MSD56 soft dome midrange looks less like the MDM55 and more like an
oversized tweeter. Featuring a commandably high Xmax value (over twice that of
the MDM55), this could be interesting for those wanting to use a dome
midrange.
- The new Shabani series woofers and mid/bass driver appear to be fairly
conventional for Morel - moderate to fairly high Qts values and
decent but hardly extreme Xmax numbers. In a significant break with Morel
tradition, they all feature cast aluminum frames.
- The Shabani MSW-12.1 subwoofer breaks with Morel tradition in most
respects. Although hardly state-of-the-art, its Xamx is significantly higher
than we've come to expect from Morel. Its Qts value is quite low, and it's
built on a cast aluminum frame.
|